New York, NY to Indianapolis, IN Moving Truck Gas Cost

Fuel cost by truck size

Based on 711 miles, a gas price of $4.197 and a diesel price of $6.430 a gallon. Towing a car on a trailer or dolly lowers fuel economy by about 15%.

Truck	MPG	Gallons	Fuel cost	Towing a car
Cargo van	16	44	$187	$219
10 to 12 ft truck	11	65	$271	$319
15 to 17 ft truck	9	79	$332	$390
20 to 22 ft truck	8	89	$373	$439
26 ft truck	7	102	$426	$502
26 ft truck (diesel)	8	89	$571	$672

The gap between the smallest and largest trucks on this route is about $240 in fuel alone, so it pays to rent only as much truck as you need.

Fuel prices at each end of the move

Where	Gas	Diesel	Price basis
New York, NY	$4.249	$6.508	New York average
Indianapolis, IN	$4.145	$6.352	Midwest average

Prices at the two ends are within a few cents of each other, so where you fill up matters less than how fast you drive.

Weekly retail averages from the U.S. Energy Information Administration for the week of October 19, 2026. Prices along the way will vary. EIA source

Planning the drive

A loaded box truck is slower than a car on hills and safest at moderate speeds, and most drivers find 450 miles a comfortable day. That makes New York, NY to Indianapolis, IN a 2-day drive, so budget for hotel nights and meals on top of fuel. The rental itself and any per-mile fees are charged separately from fuel.

Other moves

Going the other way? See Indianapolis, IN to New York, NY.

Moving truck gas cost from New York, NY to Indianapolis, IN